Coinbase Backs CFTC Rule That Would Treat Event Contracts as Swaps, Urges Open Category List
Coinbase has told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the federal agency that oversees derivatives, that it supports a proposed rule on event contracts. Event contracts are agreements that pay out based on whether a specific event happens, such as an election result or a sports outcome. The proposal would place these contracts under the federal definition of a swap, a type of derivatives contract the CFTC regulates.
Coinbase also asked the agency to make sure the rule's list of example categories is not treated as a closed set. The company wants contracts tied to crypto and other subjects to remain covered.
Key points from the letter
- Coinbase said it "strongly supports" the CFTC's plan to include event contracts in the federal swap definition.
- The company wants the rule's example categories, which include sports, politics, culture, and weather, to stay an open-ended list.
- Coinbase argues the Commodity Exchange Act, the federal derivatives law, already covers these contracts, so the rule should confirm that coverage rather than create it.
- The letter was filed on Nov. 18, the final day of the 30-day comment period.
What the comment letter says
The letter is dated Nov. 18 and addressed to CFTC Secretary Christopher Kirkpatrick. It was signed by Julia Hueckel, Coinbase's director of regulatory policy, and David Shafer, its director and associate general counsel for institutional legal.
Coinbase said a closed list of examples "would provide less certainty by inviting negative inferences" about legitimate products. It asked the CFTC to keep the word "including" in the rule and to state in the rule's preamble that the examples "do not create a closed set or a presumption against other event contract categories."
The letter named crypto-related event contracts as "representative of the type of financial event contract where price discovery, hedging, and informational value are sought by many active investors."
What the CFTC proposed
According to the Federal Register notice published Oct. 19, the CFTC would define the term swap to explicitly include event contracts, "including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural-, and weather-related events." The notice records CFTC Chairman Michael Selig voting in favor, with no commissioner voting against.
A companion interim rule states that casino-style gambling products are not swaps. Coinbase said it backed that rule in a separate letter.
Why Coinbase wants the rule framed as confirmation
Coinbase argued that the Commodity Exchange Act already covers these contracts. It asked the CFTC to frame the rule as confirming that reading, rather than implying that such contracts "become swaps only when the rule takes effect."
The letter pointed to state enforcement actions and split federal court rulings as the source of uncertainty for exchanges and their customers.
Coinbase also suggested the CFTC state that its cost-benefit analysis holds "even if a court concluded that the relevant baseline involved States exercising regulatory authority over sports-related and other event contracts."
A long-standing regulatory question
Austin Campbell, host of Unchained's Bits + Bips, described the issue on the show as a question "created with the passage of Dodd-Frank that has not been answered at all." Dodd-Frank is the financial reform law that brought swaps under federal oversight. Campbell said there were "many sort of informal understandings and zero formal understanding" on one point: "When is something a swap and when is it not a swap?"
Coinbase's stake in the market
Coinbase owns Coinbase Derivatives, a CFTC-registered exchange. It also offers event contracts to customers nationwide through its brokerage arm.