Coinbase, Kalshi and Kraken's parent back CFTC in court fight over single-stock perpetual futures
Crypto firms ask court to back CFTC in perps lawsuit
Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward (the parent company of crypto exchange Kraken), DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm have asked a federal court for permission to file a legal brief supporting the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the U.S. agency that regulates derivatives. The filing was made in a Monday court document.
The brief would respond to a lawsuit filed last week by the Capital Markets Alliance (CMA), an industry association whose members include Cboe and Citadel Securities. The CMA wants a court to overturn the CFTC's approval of single-stock perpetual futures in the U.S.
Key points
- Six firms — Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward, DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm — moved for leave to file an amicus brief, a document from a non-party offering views to the court, in support of the CFTC.
- The CMA argues the products should be treated as "security-based swaps" rather than futures, and that the CFTC overstepped the Securities and Exchange Commission's authority.
- Coinbase, Kalshi and Payward have applications with the CFTC to list equity perps tied to U.S. stocks; those applications were deemed approved on Nov. 2.
What perpetual futures are
Perpetual futures, often called perps, are derivatives that let traders bet on an asset's price without owning it. Unlike traditional futures contracts, they have no expiration date. The new products apply this structure to individual U.S. stocks.
The dispute over who regulates the products
The CMA argues that because equity perps never expire, they should not be treated as futures. Instead, the association says they are "security-based swaps," which cannot be listed on CFTC-regulated exchanges, and that the CFTC overstepped the SEC's authority.
The crypto firms pushed back in the Monday filing. They said the SEC was "at the table from the very start" of the regulatory process, and that the agencies jointly sought public comment on whether perpetual contracts should be classified as security futures.
What Coinbase executives say
Coinbase general counsel Molly Abraham wrote on X that under the Commodity Exchange Act and the securities futures framework Congress set up in 2000, security futures products are not swaps.
Coinbase Vice Chairman Ryan VanGrack said global markets are already trading equity perps. "U.S. investors deserve access to these markets under the strong consumer protections and joint oversight of the CFTC and SEC," he wrote on X. "The U.S. should lead, not cede, this space."
What is confirmed and what is not
The court filing, the CMA lawsuit and the companies' requests are documented. The Nov. 2 deemed approval of the firms' CFTC applications is reported by The Block and cited in the filing. The claims about who has legal authority over the products are arguments made by each side in the dispute — the court has not yet ruled. It is also not yet known whether the court will grant permission for the brief to be filed.
Why it matters
According to The Block, a court decision upholding the CFTC's approvals would help preserve the path for these firms to offer or expand single-stock perps onshore in the U.S. Coinbase, Kalshi and Payward each have pending or approved applications tied to these products.