Hill and Moreno say delays sank the Clarity Act but split on how far regulators can go
Two US lawmakers say Congress missed its best chance to pass the Clarity Act, a bill that would set clear rules for how digital assets are regulated. Rep. French Hill and Sen. Bernie Moreno both blame delays for the failure, but they disagree on how much can be done by regulators alone while the bill remains stalled.
The two spoke in separate interviews on Thursday at The Hill and The Block's Capitol Crypto Forum.
Key points from the forum
- Both lawmakers said it was a mistake to advance the GENIUS Act, a stablecoin law, separately from the Clarity Act.
- The Clarity Act passed the House but failed a Senate vote in September.
- Moreno said regulators could deliver about 80% of a crypto framework through rulemaking.
- Hill said agency action is not a permanent fix and does not have the force of law.
- Neither expects the bill to pass during the lame-duck session, the period after an election before new members take office.
Moreno sees regulators doing most of the work
Moreno, an Ohio Republican, said he is more optimistic than Hill about what regulators can achieve on their own. "I'm a little bit more bullish than French," he said. "I think it can accomplish 80% through a very rigorous rulemaking process that can't be unwound."
He said the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the two main US market regulators, should use the next two years to set rules that a future administration would find hard to undo.
Still, he acknowledged this is not the ideal path. "Is that the right way to do it? No," he said. "I think the right way to do it is Congress should pass the Clarity Act."
Hill says agency rules cannot replace law
Hill, an Arkansas Republican who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, said regulators have largely followed the goals of market structure bills since the Clarity Act failed. But he said their authority has limits.
"My argument is it's not a permanent fix. It is subject to litigation. It does not have the force of law," Hill said.
Why the bill lost momentum
Hill said he urged the Senate and the administration last summer to pass the Clarity Act and the GENIUS Act together in the House, and he still stands by that view.
Moreno gave a sales analogy for the breakdown, saying "time kills all deals." He said lawmakers failed to use the momentum from the stablecoin legislation. He also noted the bill grew from 300 pages to 600 pages.
The Clarity Act's Senate vote failed in September amid an ethics dispute over President Donald Trump's crypto wealth, according to The Block.
Chances in the lame-duck session
Asked what could realistically pass in the coming weeks, Moreno answered: "Zero. Zero."
Hill was slightly more hopeful, saying lawmakers "never give up hope in a lame duck," though "the chances are not high."
Could talks restart?
Hill said it was a good sign that Rep. Maxine Waters identified digital asset market structure as an issue she would address if elected as committee chair.
Moreno said bipartisan negotiations are not off the table. He blamed earlier talks for being "tornadoed" in disputes over Trump and ethics. He said he would consider restarting negotiations based on the House-passed version of the bill.
"By the time we got to September with the Senate version, it was just very, very, very complicated," Moreno said.
Hill argued Congress still needs to finish the work. "To have GENIUS but not market structure is a huge mistake," he said.
What this means for crypto rules
The exchange shows that the US still has no dedicated market structure law for digital assets. Until one passes, the main regulators are expected to keep writing rules on their own, which Hill warns could be challenged in court and undone by a future administration.