Social Security faces a 22% cut by 2032. Sen. Ron Johnson's answer: let Treasury borrow the difference
Social Security runs short in 2032, and a Senate chairman wants Treasury to fill the gap
Social Security's retirement trust fund is less than six years from running out of money. When it does, benefits would be cut automatically by about 22%. Senate Budget Committee Chairman Ron Johnson, a Republican from Wisconsin, has a plan to stop that: let the Treasury borrow the difference.
Johnson put the proposal forward on Nov. 18. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB), a nonpartisan group that pushes for lower deficits, calls it the Stop Scaring Seniors Act. The bill would let the Treasury Secretary move money from the government's general fund into the retirement trust fund once its reserves are gone, so the roughly 70 million people collecting benefits would keep receiving full checks.
The numbers behind the plan
- The retirement trust fund is projected to run dry in 2032, which would trigger an automatic benefit cut of about 22%, according to a CRFB chart published by Fortune.
- CRFB estimates the borrowing plan would add $190 trillion to the national debt over 75 years, in inflation-adjusted terms, or 165% of GDP.
- The 22% cut equals about $500 a month for the average beneficiary, per CRFB.
- A Senate Budget Committee report Johnson released the same day projects a Social Security shortfall of about $511 billion by 2032.
What the deficit watchdog says
CRFB argues the bigger danger is not decades away. "We usually say that inaction is the worst option when it comes to Social Security, but now we found something even worse," CRFB president Maya MacGuineas said in a statement. She called the bill hard to see as anything other than "a cynical pander that ducks all the real decisions we need to confront."
"Even simply passing the legislation could spook the bond market enough to spark financial turmoil," MacGuineas said, adding that the borrowing "would almost certainly spark a crisis."
The group has modeled this type of fix before. In an analysis last November, CRFB estimated that funding Social Security from general revenue would push interest rates up by about 2.6 percentage points compared with keeping the trust fund intact. In that scenario, the 10-year Treasury yield would rise from 4% to 6.6%, and 30-year mortgage rates would go from 6.3% to 8.9%. CRFB also estimated the change would raise U.S. debt by 132% of GDP by 2099, and said the trust fund would stop acting as a budget rule and become "more like any other government program."
Johnson's argument for the bill
Johnson argues Americans have been misled about how Social Security is funded. A Senate Budget Committee report he released on Nov. 18 is titled "Social Security: The Reality… a Legal Ponzi Scheme."
"Your money was spent to pay current beneficiaries or fund other government programs," Johnson said, according to the National News Desk. He said future benefits will be paid with money from "your sons and daughters working at that time," plus borrowing.
MacGuineas agreed with part of his argument. Johnson says Congress should fix the overall deficit instead of treating Social Security separately, and she called that "a reasonable position." But she said a law "that fails to fix Social Security while ballooning the debt" was not the way to do it, and suggested lawmakers work out a fix, perhaps through a bipartisan commission.
How Social Security pays benefits now
Social Security has paid benefits out of payroll taxes since the 1930s. By law, it can only pay what its trust fund holds. That is why benefits drop automatically when the fund runs out. Johnson's plan would remove that limit and send the bill to the Treasury, which already borrows to cover the government's deficit.
The bill's name has a history
Johnson has used this framing before. In July 2011, he and 12 other freshman Senate Republicans sent then-President Barack Obama a letter accusing him of trying to "scare seniors" by warning that Social Security checks could be at risk if Congress did not raise the debt ceiling.
The debt ceiling is coming back. TD Securities expects the current $41.1 trillion limit to start binding in January, with the government running out of room by around September 2027. That is five years before the trust fund runs out, and Johnson's bill would put Social Security on the same borrowed money.
What is confirmed and what is not
Confirmed from the sources: the bill was introduced on Nov. 18; CRFB's $190 trillion and 165%-of-GDP debt estimate; the projected 2032 depletion and 22% cut; the roughly $500 monthly cut for the average beneficiary; the 2011 letter; and TD Securities' debt ceiling forecast.
The interest rate figures come from a CRFB analysis of a general-revenue fix, not from the specific bill. Whether the bill will pass, and whether the bond market would react as CRFB warns, is not known. CRFB's debt and rate figures are its estimates, not official government projections.
Why this matters for beneficiaries and taxpayers
About 70 million people collect Social Security benefits. Without action, they face an automatic cut of about 22%, or roughly $500 a month for the average beneficiary, in 2032. The debate is over who pays instead: current and future taxpayers through more borrowing, or beneficiaries through lower checks. The plan also connects to a nearer deadline, since the government is expected to hit its borrowing limit well before 2032.
What comes next
The bill has been introduced but its path in Congress is not laid out in the sources. MacGuineas has suggested lawmakers address the shortfall through a bipartisan commission instead. The debt ceiling fight is expected to start in January, per TD Securities' forecast.