Trump's CFTC nominees face Senate questions over prediction market oversight
President Donald Trump's two nominees to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or CFTC, faced questions from senators about who should regulate prediction markets, including platforms that offer sports betting contracts. The hearing was held by the Senate Agriculture Committee.
The nominees are Matthew Rowland, a Democrat, and Nathan Anonick, a Republican. If confirmed, they would join CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, who is currently the agency's only Republican commissioner.
Key points from the hearing
- Senators focused on prediction markets and whether the CFTC or the states should oversee sports betting contracts.
- Sen. Tina Smith, a Democrat from Minnesota, said sports gambling jurisdiction belongs to states and tribes, and said prediction markets operate in violation of those laws.
- Rowland said he is sympathetic to the concerns of states and tribes and would want to work with them if confirmed.
- Anonick called the issue "very charged" and said he planned to listen to stakeholders, a framing Smith pushed back on.
- Nearly a dozen states and the CFTC have sued each other, and the issue could reach the Supreme Court.
What the nominees said
Rowland pointed to Regulation 40.11, a rule the CFTC adopted in 2011. It stops registered exchanges from listing certain event contracts tied to gaming, terrorism, war, and assassination. He declined to comment on the active litigation but said he would want to work with states and tribes if confirmed.
Anonick said the CFTC has discretion to decide whether a contract is against the public interest, and that the debate over gaming is a "very charged emotional issue."
Smith disagreed with that framing. "I would just argue that, friendly pushback, that I don't think that this is an emotional issue," she said. "I think this is a legal issue."
The fight over who regulates prediction markets
Prediction markets let people trade contracts on whether future events will happen. Under Chairman Michael Selig, the CFTC has claimed "exclusive jurisdiction" over event contracts. In proposed rulemaking, the agency has argued that prediction market contracts qualify as swaps, which are financial agreements based on future events, placing them under federal commodities oversight rather than state gambling laws.
States take a different view. They argue the platforms are running illegal gambling businesses while avoiding state regulations and taxes. Tribal organizations have also warned the platforms could get around existing tribal-state gaming agreements.
The legal battle is ongoing. Courts have taken opposing sides, and the dispute could go all the way to the Supreme Court for a final decision.
What happens next
The Senate Agriculture Committee must vote on the nominees before they go to a full Senate vote. The timing is tight ahead of a new Congress in January. If the process is not completed, the nominations would generally have to be resubmitted.