US judge acquits MIT-educated brothers in $25 million Ethereum trading case
A US judge has acquitted two MIT-educated brothers who were accused of stealing $25 million in cryptocurrency in just 12 seconds. US District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan ruled on Monday that prosecutors failed to prove the brothers committed fraud.
The case centered on Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, both computer programmers. Prosecutors said they exploited a software bug to take the money from other traders on the Ethereum network, a blockchain, which is a public ledger that records every cryptocurrency transaction.
Judge ends a case a jury could not decide
Judge Clarke issued her decision one year after a jury deadlocked, meaning jurors could not agree on whether to convict or acquit the brothers. The charges involved a type of fraud scheme that prosecutors said had never before been federally prosecuted.
Clarke wrote that the question before the court was not whether the brothers' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes. She said the question was simply whether the trial evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to the government, could support wire fraud and related convictions. She found it could not.
What prosecutors said happened
According to prosecutors, the brothers spent months plotting to manipulate the protocols used to validate transactions on the Ethereum blockchain. Validators are participants who check that new transactions are valid before they are added to the ledger.
Prosecutors alleged that in April 2023, the brothers exploited a vulnerability in software code called MEV-Boost, which is used by most Ethereum validators. They described the scheme as a high-speed bait-and-switch designed to lure trading bots into a trap and drain the accounts of other cryptocurrency traders.
The brothers were indicted in May 2024. Both graduated from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where prosecutors said they developed the skills they relied on for their trading strategy. According to defense lawyers, Anton earned a bachelor's degree in computer science and engineering in 2023. James earned a bachelor's degree in mathematics and aeronautics in 2019 and a master's degree in aeronautics in 2021.
Why the judge said the evidence fell short
Clarke said prosecutors failed to present evidence showing the brothers made any material misrepresentations when they carried out the alleged scheme. Without misrepresentations, she ruled, they could not be convicted of wire fraud and other charges.
She said the transactions the brothers engaged in contained no misrepresentations and were not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct.
How the defense and prosecutors responded
Daniel Marx, a lawyer for Anton Peraire-Bueno at Fick & Marx, said in a statement that the ruling made clear the brothers never lied to anyone about their trading activity. He said the prosecution was based on fundamental misunderstandings about decentralized financial networks like Ethereum.
Katherine Trefz, a lawyer for James Peraire-Bueno at Williams & Connolly, called the decision the just and correct outcome.
A spokesperson for US Attorney James McDonald, whose office prosecuted the case, declined to comment.
What is confirmed and what is not
Confirmed by the ruling: the judge found the trial evidence could not support wire fraud and related convictions, and the brothers are acquitted.
The claim that the brothers stole $25 million in 12 seconds was an allegation by prosecutors. The judge's ruling means they were not convicted of the charged crimes, but the article's source does not describe any further legal steps by prosecutors.
Why this case matters for crypto
The case was described by prosecutors as the first federal prosecution of this type of fraud scheme. The acquittal means a judge has found that exploiting a software bug in this way did not amount to wire fraud under the evidence presented, because the transactions involved no misrepresentations and occurred outside a regulated market. The source material does not say what effect the ruling will have on future cases.