USDA rule changes leave rural solar grant applicants in limbo, Fortune commentary says
The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) changed the rules of a federal renewable energy grant program this year, and the changes have left farmers, rural small businesses, and grant consultants with stalled projects and lost income. The account comes from a Fortune commentary published on November 22, 2026, written by Veronica McFadden, founder of an Iowa grant consulting firm.
The piece is an opinion article, not a straight news report. Its author runs a business that helps people apply for the program in question and is involved in a lawsuit against the USDA over the new rules. Readers should keep that context in mind.
Key points from the commentary
- In March, USDA announced it would stop processing pending applications for the Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) and make no new grant awards until new regulations take effect. Applicants who followed the old rules would have to start over.
- REAP is a federal program created by Congress in the 2002 farm bill to encourage renewable energy and energy efficiency investments by farmers and rural small businesses. It was reauthorized in the 2018 farm bill, which President Trump signed.
- In October, USDA issued a new rule that generally requires applicants to complete projects, pay the bills, and document 12 months of energy production or savings before they can apply for reimbursement.
- The author says her firm laid off all five employees this year after 57 client applications were caught in the March decision, representing more than $22 million in planned rural energy investments and more than $9 million in grant awards.
- In September, the Environmental Law and Policy Center filed a lawsuit against the USDA over the new anti-solar measures. The Iowa Farmers Union and the Iowa Solar Energy Trade Association are plaintiffs.
What the commentary says happened to applicants
McFadden describes the case of Ron Rusk, a Michigan dairy farmer whose REAP application she helped prepare. According to the commentary, Rusk applied under the previous rules and then invested about $86,000 in solar equipment, seeking a grant covering roughly a quarter of the cost. The March decision left his application in limbo, and the October rule terminated it.
Under the October rule, USDA itself acknowledges, in the commentary's words, "some uncertainty about whether an applicant will receive an award." McFadden argues this turns an investment incentive into what she calls a reimbursement lottery, because the businesses that most need help are often least able to spend their own money first and wait a year or more for a grant decision.
Figures and studies cited in the piece
The commentary cites several outside sources:
- The National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition estimates that each REAP grant dollar generates $8.72 in total project spending, supporting work for electricians, installers, manufacturers, and rural contractors.
- USDA's own budget documents say REAP projects give farmers and rural small businesses "new and sustainable income streams," according to the commentary.
- USDA research found that solar and wind installations directly occupied less than 0.05% of US farmland in 2020.
- A Brookings analysis found that about two-thirds of REAP grants went to districts now represented by Republicans, and 18 of the 20 districts receiving the most grants are Republican-held.
The policy disagreement at the center
The commentary points to a conflict between Congress and the agency. It says Congress instructed USDA to "promote" renewable energy and efficiency for rural businesses, while USDA's own new rule states that the policies behind it direct the agency to "disincentivize solar development on farmland." McFadden argues an agency cannot rewrite a statute through policy.
She also questions the administration's reasoning. In March, USDA vowed to end "taxpayer handouts" for renewable energy, and the president's executive order targets "market distorting subsidies." Yet in October, USDA announced $8 billion in assistance to farmers facing higher fuel costs. The commentary asks why fuel relief is acceptable while grants that would permanently lower energy bills are not.
One detail the commentary highlights: REAP grants count as taxable income, and USDA says a farmer can claim the grant alongside the federal solar tax credit.
What is confirmed and what is opinion
Confirmed from the supplied material: USDA announced the March pause on pending REAP applications in official documents, issued the October rule through the Federal Register, and announced $8 billion in fuel-cost assistance in October. The September lawsuit by the Environmental Law and Policy Center is documented in an Earthjustice press release. The USDA land-use research, the Brookings district analysis, and the coalition's spending estimate are all published sources cited in the piece.
Claims and judgments in the piece, such as the "reimbursement lottery" characterization and the argument about political irony, are the author's opinions. Fortune notes that commentary pieces reflect the views of their authors, not necessarily those of Fortune. The author's own business losses, including the layoffs and the 57 affected applications, come from her first-person account and are not independently verified in the supplied material.
Why it matters for rural energy projects
REAP is not a grant with no strings attached, the commentary stresses. Farmers and business owners put their own capital at risk, hire private contractors, and pay the costs grants do not cover. The rule changes affect people who already made those investments based on the old rules, as well as anyone considering applying in the future. The pending lawsuit will help determine whether the new rules stand.