Yale professors say Nvidia's board checked every governance box and still missed the crisis

Yale professors say Nvidia's board checked every governance box and still missed the crisis

A Fortune opinion column by three Yale researchers argues that Nvidia's recent leadership crisis shows standard corporate governance checklists do not guarantee a well-run board. The column, written by Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, Steven Tian, and Stephen Henriques and published on November 17, 2026, responds to the ouster of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang.

The authors say Nvidia passed nearly every common governance test used by proxy advisory firms ISS and Glass Lewis, yet the board still failed to catch serious problems. Proxy advisors are firms that tell shareholders how to vote on company matters.

Key points from the column

  • The authors say Nvidia's strong earnings release shows the company does not need Jensen Huang back as CEO.
  • They report that interim CEO Colette Kress raised forecasts and was praised for how she ran the earnings call.
  • They say new board chair Harvey Jones closed the door on Huang's return, amid news that the SEC is probing Huang and Nvidia.
  • The authors argue Nvidia met most checklist standards: nearly all directors were independent, there was an independent lead director, annual elections for every board seat, and a one-vote-per-share structure.
  • In June, shareholders re-elected all ten directors, and the authors say the CEO received 99% of the vote, with ISS supporting the full director slate.

Two camps the authors criticize

The column pushes back against two groups. The first is a small group of tech supporters calling for Huang's return. The authors say these supporters ignore the investigations into Huang's conduct and his apparent violations of Nvidia's code of conduct. They point to a post on X by Telegram founder Pavel Durov, who wrote: "Jensen made a rookie mistake. He had a board." The authors argue that anyone running a company owes a duty to shareholders first.

The second group is governance advocates the authors call "governistas." They say these critics offer solutions that do not fit the facts. For example, they say University of Delaware's Charlie Elson blamed dual-class shares, a structure where founders hold shares with extra voting power. But Nvidia has a single class of stock. They also say governance professor Richard LeBlanc of York University proposed an independent chair, even though Nvidia already had an independent lead director, former Cooley Law Firm CEO Stephen Neal.

What the column says about checklist governance

The authors argue that companies with strong governance ratings have still collapsed. They note that Enron had 12 independent directors out of 14, separated the chair and CEO roles in its final year, and was named by one governance publication as one of America's five best boards in 2000, shortly before its fraud was exposed. They add that Silicon Valley Bank had an independent chair and that 10 of Lehman Brothers' 11 directors were independent.

They also cite Stanford researchers who tested ISS's governance rating against five measures of company performance, including restatements, shareholder lawsuits, and stock performance. According to the column, the researchers found no significant correlation with any of them.

The lessons the authors draw

The column lists five lessons for boards:

  • Do not build a business on other people's money and then resent accountability to them.
  • Do not rely on simple metrics that miss the actual process of governance.
  • Do not treat share structure, whether dual-class or single-class, as a measure of board quality or independence.
  • Do not accept vague appeals to "good faith" as a substitute for real board diligence.
  • Do not depend on accountants and lawyers for protection, because responsibility stops with the board itself.

What is confirmed and what is not

This article is based on a single opinion column, so its judgments about governance are the authors' views, not settled facts. The column states as fact that Huang was ousted, that Kress is interim CEO, that Jones is board chair, and that the SEC is probing Huang and Nvidia. Details of that SEC probe are not provided in the source material and remain unclear. The column also references an unnamed Delaware Chancery Court judge it describes as ideologically charged, without naming the judge or the case.

Sources

Newisty Editorial Team
Written by

Newisty Editorial Team

Technology · Crypto · Digital Economy
View all posts

Newisty Editorial Team covers technology, cryptocurrency, digital products, online platforms, developer tools and the wider digital economy. Our content is researched from official sources, company announcements, public documentation, market data and other primary or reputable sources. Articles are reviewed and edited before publication for clarity, accuracy and useful context.

Comments (0)

Leave a comment
Your comment will appear publicly after submission.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!