$17 billion DoorDash-Instacart deal draws attention to shared board members at rival companies
DoorDash agrees to buy Instacart for $17 billion
DoorDash has agreed to buy Instacart for $17 billion in a cash-and-stock deal. The two companies are rivals in food and grocery delivery. They also share an unusual link: partners from the same venture firm, Sequoia Capital, sit on both companies' boards.
The deal has drawn attention because the US Department of Justice (DOJ) is reportedly already investigating a similar board setup at venture firm Andreessen Horowitz, also known as a16z. According to Reuters, which cited anonymous sources, the DOJ will also review the DoorDash-Instacart merger itself.
Key points
- DoorDash will pay $65 a share for Instacart, a 26% premium to Instacart's closing price on the last trading day before media reports of a possible deal.
- Instacart's board approved the deal unanimously, but it still needs approval from Instacart shareholders and regulators, including in Canada and Israel.
- The companies expect the deal to close in late 2027 or the first half of 2028.
- Talks about a combination in 2021 ended over antitrust concerns.
- The Federal Trade Commission declined to comment on a review of the purchase.
The Sequoia board overlap at the center of the story
Alfred Lin, a partner at Sequoia Capital, sits on DoorDash's board. Ravi Gupta, also a Sequoia partner, is Instacart's lead independent director. Gupta, Instacart's former CFO and COO, joined the Instacart board in 2023, days after its IPO, and has been lead independent director since August 2025.
Securities filings show DoorDash has paid Lin more than $1.3 million in cash and restricted stock units for board service since it went public in 2020. Gupta has earned a combined $925,000 in cash and restricted stock in the three years since joining Instacart's board.
Instacart, whose parent company is Maplebear Inc., names DoorDash as a rival in its annual financial report. DoorDash does not name Instacart as a competitor, but it used Instacart as a peer for pay benchmarking from 2021 to July 2025, meaning DoorDash's board compared Instacart's executive pay levels with its own.
What antitrust scholars say
Mark Lemley, a professor at Stanford Law School, said a danger of interlocking directors is that companies become less likely to compete, because directors have duties to both companies and do not want one company to hurt the other. He also said directors could encourage companies to merge, eliminating competition altogether.
"I think this merger raises all sorts of antitrust alarm bells, though in the current administration it is anyone's guess whether the government will act to block it," Lemley said in an email. He also wrote, before the deal was announced, that he suspected the DoorDash and Instacart board overlaps were illegal.
Duke University law professor Yaron Nili said the venture capital model makes the industry more open to this problem. VC firms invest in many companies in the same field and put their people on the boards of the ones that succeed. Those directors often stay on boards even after companies go public.
"Now, each of them does both," Nili said of DoorDash and Instacart, which started in restaurant delivery and groceries respectively. "They're increasingly encroaching on each other's territory."
The law has limits and exceptions
Antitrust rules generally prohibit people from serving on the boards of competing companies. But the law has carveouts. It does not apply if either company has less than about $5.4 million in competitive sales, meaning revenue from products or services the two firms sell in competition with each other. It also does not apply if those competitive sales are less than 2% of either company's total sales, or less than 4% of each company's total sales.
In 2025, Instacart reported revenue of $3.7 billion, while DoorDash posted revenue of $13.7 billion. DoorDash began pushing into grocery and retail delivery in 2020 and has been moving into Instacart's supermarket-delivery lane. DoorDash CEO Tony Xu called grocery "the fastest-growing part" of the company's marketplace business during its August earnings call. Instacart partners with Uber Eats for the restaurant meals it delivers.
Lemley said he believed the two companies have at least some overlap, but noted that antitrust has a complex market definition process that agencies would need to go through if the case were contested. Van Loo noted that the law gives companies one year after they become competitors before a board member should step off. "There's no lifetime grandfather clause for antitrust enforcement," he said.
A study found thousands of rival-board overlaps
A study published in the Columbia Law Review last year documented how common these overlaps are. The study, called "Anticompetitive Directors," was co-authored by Lemley, Wharton School professor Rory Van Loo, and judicial law clerk Lane Miles. It used PitchBook data covering more than 75,000 public companies, private businesses, and startups, 454,334 investors, and 3.8 million people with fund or company roles.
The study found 1,777 cases of a single person sitting on the boards of two direct competitors, touching 2,309 companies. It also found 4,632 cases in which two employees of the same investment firm sat on rival boards, the same type of setup reportedly being probed at a16z. It found that 65% of individuals serving on competing boards were leaders at private equity firms, venture capital firms, or other investment funds.
Van Loo said the authors first discussed their findings with the DOJ in 2025, and one co-author went deeper into the analysis with officials on a call in July 2026. He said there was "a lot of interest" and called it "baffling" that the issue had not received more visible attention.
Other firms with similar overlaps
Fortune's review of board disclosures, securities filings, and venture firm websites found more examples of the pattern the DOJ is reportedly probing.
At the a16z case, the issue involves Ben Horowitz's seat on the board of analytics platform Databricks and firm partner Martin Casado's seat on the board of Fivetran, a rival platform.
Iconiq Capital has invested in AI-based accounting and financial firms FloQast, HighRadius, and Rillet, which compete for the same customers. Iconiq led a $125 million funding round in HighRadius in 2020. When Iconiq partner Roy Luo joined FloQast's board in 2024 alongside a $100 million investment, he called FloQast "a leading driver of transformation within the accounting and finance industry." HighRadius now describes itself on its website as "the best FloQast alternative for AI-powered close and consolidation." In August, Iconiq led a $100 million round that valued AI accounting platform Rillet at $1 billion, and Iconiq general partner Seth Pierrepont is now on the Rillet board.
Fortune also identified an overlap at cloud application-hosting platforms Render and Netlify. Bessemer Venture Partners' Elliott Robinson describes himself as serving on the boards of both companies, and both have Bessemer's financial backing.
What is confirmed
- DoorDash agreed to buy Instacart for $17 billion at $65 a share, a 26% premium to the last closing price before media reports of a possible deal.
- Instacart's board unanimously approved the agreement; shareholder and regulatory approvals, including in Canada and Israel, are still needed.
- Sequoia partner Alfred Lin sits on DoorDash's board, and Sequoia partner Ravi Gupta is Instacart's lead independent director.
- Instacart names DoorDash as a rival in its annual report; DoorDash used Instacart for pay benchmarking from 2021 to July 2025.
- Reuters reported, citing anonymous sources, that the DOJ will review the merger.
- The DOJ investigation of a16z over board arrangements was reported earlier this year by Bloomberg.
What is still unclear
- The DOJ review of the DoorDash-Instacart merger comes from anonymous sources; the FTC declined to comment.
- It is not certain the board overlaps are illegal. The law's carveouts depend on how much the companies' sales actually compete, and Lemley said agencies would need to go through a complex market definition process to make the case.
- Lemley said it is anyone's guess whether the government will act to block the merger.
- DoorDash, Instacart, and Sequoia did not respond to multiple requests for comment. Iconiq partners, Bessemer, and the companies involved in the other examples also did not respond to requests for comment.
Why this matters beyond delivery apps
The deal puts a spotlight on a practice that appears widespread in venture capital: partners from the same firm sitting on the boards of competing companies. Regulators have shown interest in the issue, and the reported a16z probe and the reported DOJ review of this merger suggest the practice is now under scrutiny. The companies involved say the deal is expected to close in late 2027 or the first half of 2028.