Federal Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Exploit Case
Judge dismisses charges against brothers in Ethereum exploit case
A federal judge has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges related to a $25 million exploit involving Ethereum trading bots. U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke ruled on Monday, November 16, that prosecutors did not prove the brothers made any false statements during the 2023 incident. Ethereum is a blockchain, which is a digital ledger that records transactions across a network of computers.
The ruling effectively ends the case against the brothers, who were accused of using technical bugs to drain funds from automated trading software. The court found that the government failed to identify a specific lie or misrepresentation, which is a necessary part of a wire fraud charge.
Important case details
- The court found no evidence of material misrepresentation, leading to the acquittal on wire fraud and conspiracy charges.
- Money laundering conspiracy charges were also dropped because they were dependent on the wire fraud finding.
- The acquittal comes one year after a previous trial in 2024 ended with a deadlocked jury.
- The case involved the use of bait transactions to exploit a bug in code used to order blockchain transactions.
The court's reasoning for acquittal
Judge Clarke stated that while the brothers' conduct could be questioned on moral grounds, it did not meet the legal definition of wire fraud. She noted that the prosecution never showed that the defendants lied to anyone about their trading activity. Wire fraud requires a specific false statement or misrepresentation to be criminal.
The judge also clarified that Ethereum is not a regulated market with established rules against this specific type of trading conduct. She noted that the bait transactions were actual transactions published to the blockchain, rather than fake orders intended to be canceled. Evidence that the brothers tried to hide their identities after the event was not enough to replace the missing evidence of a false statement.
Legal defense responses
Attorneys for both brothers expressed satisfaction with the court's decision. Daniel Marx, a lawyer for Anton, said the ruling shows the brothers never lied to anyone about what they were doing. Katherine Trefz, representing James, described the acquittal as the correct and just outcome.
Facts of the 2023 incident
The incident involved maximal extractable value (MEV), which refers to profit that can be made by controlling how transactions are ordered inside a block of data. The brothers used bait transactions to lure trading bots that execute private groups of trades. By exploiting a bug in the relay code of the MEV-Boost software, they were able to see these private trades and swap the bait for their own orders. This process allowed them to take approximately $25 million in about 12 seconds. Flashbots, the developer of the software, fixed the code bug within 24 hours of the exploit.
Impact on future crypto legal cases
This ruling may set a precedent for how prosecutors handle code exploits in the crypto industry. Judge Clarke cited a similar 2025 case where a trader was acquitted of wire fraud after a $100 million exploit on the Mango Markets platform. These rulings suggest that on platforms without clear terms of use, prosecutors must identify a specific lie rather than relying on a victim's expectations or a defendant's attempts to hide their identity.