Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in Historic $25 Million Ethereum Fraud Case
Judge clears MIT brothers of wire fraud charges
A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of fraud and money laundering charges. The U.S. government had accused the MIT-educated brothers of stealing $25 million in just 12 seconds through a complex Ethereum trading scheme in April 2023.
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that outsmarting trading bots on the Ethereum network does not constitute wire fraud. This decision marks the end of the first criminal case brought by the U.S. government involving a practice known as Maximal Extractable Value (MEV). MEV refers to the profit that can be made by controlling the order of transactions on a blockchain, which is a shared digital ledger that records activity.
Key facts of the court decision
- The judge granted a judgment of acquittal for wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
- The acquittal follows a November 2025 mistrial that occurred when a jury was unable to reach a verdict.
- The court ruled that the prosecution failed to prove the brothers made a "material misrepresentation," or a lie that others relied on.
- The case involved the exploitation of a flaw in relay software, which acts as an intermediary to help process transactions on the network.
The judge's ruling on Ethereum's trustless nature
In her opinion, Judge Clarke described Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use." She emphasized that while the brothers' conduct might be considered objectionable by some, it was not necessarily criminal under current wire fraud laws. The ruling suggested that the network operates without formal agreements or rules beyond its own computer code.
How the $25 million exploit was carried out
According to the court's opinion, the brothers set a trap for trading bots by placing "bait" transactions. These bots monitor the public queue of pending transactions, called a mempool, to find profit opportunities. The bots often use a "sandwich" strategy, where they buy a token right before a large purchase and sell it immediately after the price rises.
When the brothers' own validator—a participant responsible for adding new blocks to the network—was selected to process transactions, they exploited a relay software flaw. This allowed them to see hidden transaction details and reorder them to their advantage, resulting in a $25 million profit while the trading bots lost an equal amount.
What is now confirmed
The acquittal is now official, and Judge Clarke has directed the court clerk to close the case. This legal outcome establishes that in the eyes of this court, exploiting the technical mechanics of a decentralized network like Ethereum to outmaneuver other automated traders does not meet the legal definition of wire fraud without clear proof of a lie or misrepresentation.