Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted of wire fraud in $25 million Ethereum MEV case
Judge clears brothers in $25 million Ethereum MEV case
A Manhattan federal judge has acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges. The case stemmed from a $25 million Ethereum exploit. Ethereum is a blockchain, a shared digital ledger that records crypto transactions.
Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that the brothers' trading strategy did not constitute criminal fraud under the statutes prosecutors cited. She granted their motion for acquittal after prosecutors failed to show the brothers made material misrepresentations while carrying out the scheme.
Key points from the ruling
- Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the brothers of wire fraud and related charges.
- The judge said the question was not whether the strategy was improper or unethical, but whether it was wire fraud.
- The transactions were not conducted on a regulated market where the alleged conduct would be prohibited.
- Prosecutors did not show the brothers made material misrepresentations in executing the scheme.
What the judge's ruling said
According to the ruling, the key question was whether the brothers' conduct amounted to wire fraud, not whether it was improper or unethical. The judge found the alleged conduct took place outside a regulated market where it would be prohibited, and that prosecutors failed to prove material misrepresentations.
How the case unfolded
In April 2023, a group of MEV bots lost over $25 million in seconds during a sophisticated attack on the Ethereum blockchain. MEV stands for maximal extractable value, which is the maximum amount of value that can be extracted from a decentralized finance protocol or smart contract by a user or group of users. The attacker replaced the bots' normal MEV transactions with malicious ones, causing them to lose money.
The brothers used bait transactions to manipulate other traders' sandwich bots before intercepting their trades. In May 2024, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno were arrested after prosecutors said they exploited the Ethereum blockchain.
In November 2025, a mistrial was declared after the jury deadlocked in Manhattan federal court.
Critics called the case an overreach
After the mistrial, Coin Center executive director Peter Van Valkenburgh told The Block that the case was a "massive overstep."
"A mistrial is not at all surprising to me because, gosh, if I wasn't a crypto person and I was on that jury, I would just be incredibly confused," Van Valkenburgh said at the time.