Judge acquits 'MEV brothers' over $25 million Ethereum exploit

Judge acquits 'MEV brothers' over $25 million Ethereum exploit

Judge acquits the 'MEV brothers' in $25 million Ethereum case

Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, two brothers accused of stealing $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in April 2023, have been acquitted of wire fraud and money laundering. Judge Jessica Clarke ruled on Monday that the government failed to prove the brothers made any material misrepresentations when carrying out their scheme.

The ruling came after a weeks-long trial last November ended with a deadlocked jury and was declared a mistrial.

Key points from the ruling

  • The brothers ran an Ethereum validator — a computer that helps confirm transactions on the network — and used it to exploit MEV trading bots for about $25 million in just 12 seconds in April 2023.
  • MEV stands for maximal extractable value. It refers to profits that people who order blockchain transactions can capture, often using automated trading bots.
  • The pair were indicted in May 2024 on wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit money laundering, and conspiracy to receive stolen property.
  • Judge Clarke found the brothers made no material misrepresentation to their victims, a key element needed for a wire fraud conviction.
  • The exploit took advantage of a design flaw in Flashbots' MEV-boost relay, a system used in Ethereum block building.

What the judge's ruling says

Judge Clarke's opinion is limited to whether the evidence at trial was enough to support a conviction on the charges presented. She did not rule on whether the brothers' behavior was right or moral, or whether it violated crimes that were never charged.

She wrote that Ethereum is a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," without the safeguards that exist in regulated markets. She acknowledged that the scheme may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost's design, but found that no misrepresentation in its execution could form the basis for fraud.

Clarke compared the case to Avraham Eisenberg's 2022 exploit of Mango Markets, where related charges were overturned last year using similar reasoning.

How the case unfolded

The brothers made roughly $25 million in 12 seconds through a bait-and-switch exploit of MEV trading bots. Soon after, they disclosed a different exploit to Flashbots under the name "Low Carb Crusader."

When they were indicted in May 2024, prosecutors called it a "first-of-its-kind wire fraud and money laundering scheme."

How lawyers and the brothers reacted

Crypto lawyers praised the decision, saying it invalidates the prosecution's "honest validator" theory. Peter Van Valkenburgh of crypto policy group Coin Center had worried that theory would let the government impose its own code of conduct on Ethereum validators.

Anton Peraire-Bueno, who posts as "Curious Rabbit" on X, thanked family and friends who had "rearranged their lives around this case" since the indictment, adding, "in the end, it's a good story when the good guys win." James echoed his brother's sentiment and is apparently looking forward to a celebratory beer.

What is confirmed and what is not

Confirmed by the ruling and court records: the acquittal on the charged counts, the judge's reasoning, the charges from the May 2024 indictment, and the earlier mistrial. The judge made clear her ruling does not decide whether the brothers' conduct was moral or violated uncharged laws. The $25 million figure and April 2023 date come from the reporting and earlier prosecution statements.

Sources

Newisty Editorial Team
Written by

Newisty Editorial Team

Technology · Crypto · Digital Economy
View all posts

Newisty Editorial Team covers technology, cryptocurrency, digital products, online platforms, developer tools and the wider digital economy. Our content is researched from official sources, company announcements, public documentation, market data and other primary or reputable sources. Articles are reviewed and edited before publication for clarity, accuracy and useful context.

Comments (0)

Leave a comment
Your comment will appear publicly after submission.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!