$25M Ethereum MEV acquittal leaves legal risk for staking income unresolved
Anton and James Peraire-Bueno were acquitted in a fraud case tied to about $25 million lost on Ethereum. The verdict tested the limits of criminal enforcement, but it did not settle whether profiting from the order of trades is lawful. That unanswered question matters to BlackRock, whose staked Ether ETF earns part of its income from exactly that kind of trading activity.
Key facts in the case
- Two brothers, Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, were acquitted of fraud.
- Three traders lost about $25 million when trades ran in a different order than the one the brothers' validator had signed.
- Prosecutors could not prove the signed block was a promise to publish the trades in that order.
- BlackRock had flagged the case in its fund prospectus as a risk to its staking program.
- The acquittal left the legal status of this income unresolved.
What the case turned on
To prove fraud, prosecutors had to show that signing a proposed block amounted to a promise to publish the trades in that order. A validator is a participant that proposes and confirms blocks of transactions on Ethereum. The prosecution could not establish what terms the brothers had accepted from the service that sent them the block. That gap in the evidence led to the acquittal.
Because the case rested on this narrower question, the verdict did not decide whether earning money from trade ordering is legal in general.
Why BlackRock watched the case
BlackRock's staked Ether ETF — a fund that trades on a stock exchange and holds Ether while earning staking rewards — receives a share of what traders pay to get one Ethereum transaction ahead of another. In its prospectus, the formal document filed with the SEC that describes a fund's risks, BlackRock warned that if profiting from the order of trades were found unlawful, its staking program could be disrupted.
The acquittal left that risk unresolved.
The safeguard written into BlackRock's staking deal
The case highlights the value of a provision in BlackRock's own staking agreement. When the fund wants validators to maintain controls for screening sanctioned wallets, Coinbase must obtain a binding commitment from them. If a validator breaks that promise, the fund can point to a duty the validator accepted and ask Coinbase to enforce it.
In other words, the fund relies on explicit written promises rather than assumed ones — the same kind of promise whose absence helped sink the prosecution's case.
Why this matters
The verdict shows how hard it is to prove fraud when there is no clear, accepted promise about how trades will be ordered. For funds that earn income from trade ordering, the legal risk remains open. Clear written commitments, like the one in BlackRock's staking agreement, give parties a way to enforce duties that a criminal case may not cover.