Kalshi's Quintenz says insider trading is 'just easier to see' in prediction markets than stocks
Brian Quintenz, a board member at prediction market platform Kalshi and a former commissioner of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), said insider trading is easier to spot in prediction markets than in the stock market. He made the comments Thursday at the Capitol Crypto Forum, an event hosted by The Hill and The Block.
Prediction markets are platforms where people trade contracts tied to the outcome of real events, such as elections or sports games. Insider trading means someone uses non-public information to trade.
Key points from the panel
- Quintenz said there are far more insider trading cases in the stock market than in prediction markets, and the link between a trader and an event's outcome is very direct and easy to see.
- He argued the possibility of insider trading should not make a market illegal or invalid, and that enforcement should support the work exchanges already do to prevent it.
- Former CFTC Commissioner Dan Berkovitz said exchanges also need rules on who can trade, including limits on people who can influence a contract's outcome.
- Former CFTC Commissioner Christy Goldsmith Romero said the CFTC likely needs to give exchanges more guidance on when a contract is open to manipulation.
What Quintenz told the forum
"And there are by far more insider trading cases that happen in the stock market than anything that happens in the derivatives markets or in the prediction market space," Quintenz said. "It's just easier to see because it's very direct."
He added that there is still more work to do on prevention, but said enforcement after a violation should supplement, not replace, the safeguards exchanges put in place.
Who should be allowed to trade?
Berkovitz, now vice chair of external and regulatory affairs at Millennium Management, said federal and exchange rules already ban insider trading. But he argued exchanges also need participation limits, for example covering employees of organizations involved in a contract and people who can affect its result.
"So you need rules against insider trading, you need participation limits, and you need strict anti-manipulation provisions," Berkovitz said.
He pointed to so-called mention markets, where a contract's outcome can depend on whether a person says a specific word or phrase. In those cases, the person who decides whether to say the word also decides the outcome of the trade. Berkovitz welcomed recent CFTC guidance but said more work is needed to define who has insider knowledge or control over a contract.
Call for clearer standards from the CFTC
Goldsmith Romero, now a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, said exchanges are the first line of defense against insider trading and that the CFTC probably needs to do more. She highlighted the requirement that exchanges certify their own contracts as not readily susceptible to manipulation, and said the CFTC should give exchanges clearer guidance on that standard.
Quintenz agreed more guidance would help. He said judging whether a contract is open to manipulation is a judgment call, and the CFTC should explain how it applies the standard rather than leaving each exchange to write its own.
Who regulates sports contracts?
The panel also debated oversight of sports event contracts. Berkovitz explained that the post-Dodd-Frank final rule prohibits gaming contracts through the CFTC, subject only to future regulatory amendment. He said the latest interim rule draws a line between gambling at a casino and products traded on a federally regulated exchange. A legal question remains, he said, over whether essentially the same product can be treated as a swap on one platform but not another.
Quintenz said he had submitted a comment letter in his personal capacity. He argued the Supreme Court's 2018 sports betting ruling did not give states exclusive authority, and that federal regulators can oversee exchanges while states continue to regulate casinos and sportsbooks.
Goldsmith Romero said the Supreme Court would likely take up the matter because of conflicting decisions across the Circuit Courts. "I think it's likely that the prediction markets may end up losing on the sports contracts," she said.
She also suggested the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) could become more involved as prediction markets offer more contracts tied to public companies and their stocks, and said it would help if the SEC and CFTC worked together to provide clarity.