US appeals court backs Maryland's effort to regulate Kalshi under state sports-wagering laws
A federal appeals court has ruled that Maryland can enforce its state laws against Kalshi, a prediction market where people trade contracts on real-world events. The decision adds to a string of court losses for the prediction markets industry, which has been fighting state regulators in several states.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit issued its 2-1 ruling on Wednesday, agreeing with lower courts that Maryland can regulate Kalshi under the state's sports-wagering laws. It is the third of four appellate decisions so far to side with state oversight of the industry.
Key points from the ruling
- The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 that Maryland may police Kalshi's business under its sports-wagering laws.
- Three of four recent appellate decisions have favored state oversight of prediction markets.
- Judge Roger Gregory wrote that gambling regulation has long been a traditional state power, and he would not assume Congress took that authority away without saying so clearly.
- Kalshi argues the rulings contradict each other and show no unified legal argument against prediction markets.
- The ruling lands as a 30-day deadline from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission is running out.
What the judges and Maryland's attorney general said
Judge Roger Gregory, one of the three judges on the panel, wrote in his opinion: "Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland's concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so."
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said in a Wednesday statement that the decision means Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as other sportsbooks serving Maryland residents. He said state licensing laws require sportsbooks to safeguard customer data, avoid deceptive advertising, and stop marketing to people who are barred from betting or at risk of gambling harm. "Federal commodities rules were never designed to provide those safeguards," Brown said.
Kalshi pushes back
A Kalshi spokeswoman said the courts are producing a jumbled set of conclusions. "Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong," the spokeswoman said, adding that the splintered decision, which included three separate contradictory opinions, shows there is no unified, coherent legal argument against prediction markets.
CoinDesk reports that while the decisions differ in their reasoning, a strong majority of judges have so far found the industry is in the wrong. Until the U.S. Supreme Court takes up the issue, the conflicting views leave the rules unclear.
A federal deadline is also closing in
At the same time, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal agency that oversees these markets, has issued a 30-day demand telling its regulated exchanges, including Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase, to offer their contracts in all 50 states instead of applying geographic restrictions that many states have ordered. That deadline is winding down.
This puts the companies in a difficult position. If they follow the CFTC's demand, they would be defying federal court orders. If they do not, they may run afoul of their federal regulator.
What is confirmed and what remains unsettled
Confirmed: the Fourth Circuit's 2-1 ruling, Judge Gregory's opinion, the attorney general's statement, and Kalshi's response all come from the court decision and official statements on Wednesday.
Unsettled: the appellate rulings conflict with one another in their reasoning, and the industry's legal position will likely remain unclear unless the U.S. Supreme Court eventually resolves the dispute. The sources do not say when or whether that will happen, and no next step or timeline beyond the CFTC's 30-day window was provided.
Why this matters
Prediction markets let people trade contracts tied to the outcomes of real events, and Kalshi operates them under federal oversight. The growing set of rulings in favor of state oversight means these companies face pressure from both sides: courts allowing states to restrict or regulate them, and a federal regulator pushing them to operate nationwide. How this conflict is resolved will shape where and how these platforms can legally serve customers in the U.S.